When Figuring It Out Becomes the Problem: Rumination and OCD
Dr. Ezra Cowan, Clinical Psychologist — Center for OCD and Misophonia
A conversation ends, and something feels off.
Maybe you said too much. Maybe your tone came across as dismissive. Maybe the other person's face changed when you brought something up.
So you go back over it. What exactly did I say? What did they mean by that? Was I inconsiderate? Should I reach out?
At first, this seems reasonable. You care about the relationship. You want to understand what happened so you don't repeat it.
Then one review becomes three. You remember a detail that changes the picture. You reach a conclusion, then wonder what you left out. You run it by someone else, and their answer doesn't quite land on the part that's bothering you.
The conversation is over. You are still in it.
This is one of the ways rumination shows up in OCD, and it is one of the patterns I see most often in my practice.
What I mean by rumination
When I say rumination, I mean repetitive mental reviewing, questioning, and explaining, done in an effort to feel certain, prevent a mistake, or arrive at a sense of resolution.
The defining feature is not the topic. It is that the person keeps working the problem long after the thinking has stopped producing anything new, and stopping feels impossible while something still seems unanswered.
The content can be almost anything:
Whether you did something wrong
What a thought says about you
Whether your relationship is the right one
Why you feel the way you do
Whether you made the best decision
Whether you're doing treatment correctly
These questions matter to the people asking them, sometimes enormously. But if we want to understand what keeps someone stuck, the content is the less interesting part. The more important question is what happens when the thought shows up. Does it get some consideration and then get set down? Or does it become something that has to be settled before life is allowed to continue?
"But I really need to understand this"
Part of what makes rumination so durable is that it makes sense from the inside.
Many of my clients hate how much time they spend analyzing. At the same time, they believe analyzing is the responsible thing to do:
If I don't review what happened, how will I learn?
If I don't question my intentions, how will I know I'm a good person?
If I don't think through every possibility, how do I avoid a mistake?
There is a protective logic here. The person is trying to prevent something they genuinely don't want: hurting someone, choosing badly, being careless, or discovering too late that they missed something important.
This is why "you're overthinking it" goes nowhere. To the person ruminating, stopping doesn't feel like relief. It feels like negligence. They want out from under the cost of the analysis, but they still trust the analysis itself.
The question keeps moving
Consider someone deciding whether to go to a social event.
First: do I want to go? Then: why don't I want to go? Is it anxiety? Avoidance? Am I just tired? Would staying home be self-care or giving in?
They decide to go. Now they question whether they decided for the right reasons.
Notice what happened. The problem is no longer the event. The person is now trying to establish the correct relationship with their own thoughts, feelings, and motives before they can walk out the door.
Each question is understandable on its own. Together, they form a process with no reliable stopping point. There is always another angle.
How rumination becomes part of OCD
In OCD, rumination often functions as a mental compulsion: an attempt to neutralize a distressing thought or feeling by resolving it in your head.
The intrusion might be:
What if I offended him?
The compulsive response:
Let me reconstruct the conversation, examine my intentions, predict his reaction, and figure out whether I owe him an apology.
A conclusion brings some relief. Then a new possibility appears:
But what if I'm remembering it in a way that makes me look better?
Back to reviewing.
Over time, ordinary uncertainty starts to feel like an assignment. A question appears, and the person feels obligated to work on it.
To be clear, not all repetitive thinking is OCD, and reflection has an important place in a well-lived life. The problem begins when the thinking becomes rigid, repetitive, and increasingly costly, and when stopping depends on a feeling of certainty that keeps receding.
Rumination can take over therapy, too
This pattern doesn't stay outside the therapy room.
A client describes the week. I ask a question. The client clarifies. I offer a perspective. The client explains why it doesn't quite fit.
"But there's another part you need to understand."
More context. Then an exception. Then a question about what the whole discussion means.
Everyone is working hard. Most of what's being said is logical. The client may feel we're finally getting close to describing the problem accurately.
And yet sessions keep ending in the same place: more to understand, more to answer, and very little change in how the person is actually living.
Clarification is sometimes necessary. I need to understand the person in front of me, and clients need room to say difficult things. But part of my job is noticing when the effort to explain everything has become the very pattern we're there to treat. At that point, another interpretation from me just gives the analysis more material.
The more useful question becomes:
What happens if we leave this partly unresolved and take a step anyway?
Action over analysis
The shift I work toward is helping people participate in their lives while their mind is still demanding an answer.
That might mean returning to work without knowing whether a decision was ideal. Staying in a conversation while wondering how you're coming across. Spending time with your spouse without checking whether you feel connected enough.
The pull to figure it out may still be there. The practice is letting that pull be present without making more analysis the next task.
I teach this in three parts: catch, feel, and keep going.
Catch
Notice that you've entered the familiar process. You may be replaying something, explaining it again, checking how you feel, or hunting for the detail that will finally settle it.
You don't need to pinpoint the moment it started. A simple recognition is enough:
I'm trying to get this resolved again.
Feel
Leaving the question open will likely bring anxiety, guilt, tension, or a strong sense of incompleteness.
Make room for that. Notice what it's like to carry an unanswered question without immediately going back to work on it.
This is uncomfortable. It may also feel wrong, as if you're quitting just before reaching the answer that matters. Let that feeling stay, too.
Keep going
Choose a concrete next action. Finish the email. Rejoin the conversation. Make dinner. Start the task you've been putting off.
The action can be small and ordinary. What matters is practicing movement in the absence of resolution.
Your mind will probably keep asking questions while you do it. You can hear them and keep participating in what's in front of you.
"How do I know if I'm reflecting or ruminating?"
It's a fair question. It's also one that can easily become another thing to analyze forever.
You don't need to classify every thought correctly. Look at the broader pattern:
Are you working with new information, or circling the same material?
Can you stop while some uncertainty remains?
Is the thinking helping you take a step, or repeatedly postponing one?
Sometimes you won't know. You can practice moving forward with that uncertainty as well: Maybe there's more to think about. For now, I'm going back to what I was doing.
The goal is flexibility. There are times to reflect, times to seek advice, and times to make a practical call. And there are times when the next step is available even though your mind hasn't finished its discussion.
You may still feel unresolved
A common trap: people disengage from rumination, then check whether it worked.
Am I calmer? Have I accepted the uncertainty? Why am I still thinking about it?
Now stopping rumination has become the next thing to review.
You don't have to feel finished for the practice to count. You may go back to what you were doing with the question still nagging at you. You may get pulled back in and have to return again, and again.
Meaningful change can look like finishing a task, sharing a meal, or having a conversation while part of your attention is still drawn to the unresolved question. For someone used to thinking until things feel settled, that is not a small step. It is the work.
There may be a question you've been carrying for hours, days, or much longer. Before you give it another round, ask yourself what you've been waiting to do until it's resolved.
Then take one step into that part of your life, with the question still open.

